CO-22 vs CO-24 vs CO-109 denial: three “bill someone else” denials
All three say this payer will not pay. Each one sends you to a different place. Here is how to tell them apart.
The short answer
These three look alike, but the fix is different.
- CO-22: another payer may be primary (coordination of benefits). Bill the other payer first.
- CO-24: the charges are covered under a capitation agreement. Bill the capitated plan or medical group.
- CO-109: this payer does not cover the claim. You must send it to the correct payer.
A quick way to remember: 22 is about order, 24 is about who is paid a fixed amount, and 109 is about the wrong payer.
Side by side
| CO-22 | CO-24 | CO-109 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Payer says | Covered by another payer per COB | Charges covered under a capitation agreement | Not covered by this payer. Send to the correct payer |
| What it usually means | The patient has another insurance that should pay first | The patient is assigned to a capitated plan or medical group | The claim went to the wrong insurance |
| Ask the payer | Who is primary? Is the other insurance active? | Which plan or group is the patient assigned to? | Who is the primary payer? |
| Where to send it | To the primary first, then the secondary | To the capitated plan or group | To the correct payer, with this one as secondary if needed |
| Related page | Coordination of benefits | Capitation | CO-109 page |
How to work CO-22
- Check the claim status. Decide if the denial is valid.
- Ask the payer what other insurance they have on file and for which dates.
- Verify that the other insurance was active on the date of service.
- Update the coordination of benefits in your system.
- Bill the primary first. When it pays, send the claim to the secondary with the primary’s EOB or ERA.
- If the other insurance was not active, ask the payer to update their records and reprocess. Note the name and the call reference number.
How to work CO-24
- Confirm which capitated plan or medical group the patient was assigned to on the date of service.
- Bill that plan or group. This payer will not pay the service.
- If the patient was not assigned to that group on the date of service, ask the payer to reprocess, with proof.
How to work CO-109
- Call the insurance and ask for the details of the primary payer.
- Get the insurance name, policy number, payer ID and effective dates. Verify eligibility.
- Bill that insurance and make the current one secondary.
- If the information the representative gives is not active on the date of service, ask them to reprocess the claim.
- If the representative has nothing, check the supporting documents and the member history. If you find nothing, contact the patient.
Common mistakes
- Resubmitting to the same payer without changing anything.
- Billing the secondary before the primary has paid.
- Not keeping the primary EOB, so the secondary cannot process it.
- Missing the timely filing limit while chasing the right payer. Calculate it early.
Questions people ask
What is capitation?
An agreement where the insurance pays a provider or group a fixed sum to care for a certain number of patients, in a certain region, for a certain time period. That is why CO-24 sends you to the capitated plan.
Can I bill the patient for these?
Not while another payer may owe the money. Find the right payer first. When the group code is CO, the amount cannot be billed to the patient.
What if I cannot find the right payer?
Check the supporting documents and the member’s history, then contact the patient for their insurance details. Write a note of every step.
Updated November 2026. For education only. Payer rules differ, so confirm important details with the payer or your client.
Denial code pages mentioned here
Each code opens its own page on MBillers with the reason and the corrective action.
Keep learning
Related comparisons and pages from MBillers.
Would you like to help our billing family?
Help us keep MBillers accurate and up to date by reporting incorrect information, sharing valuable medical billing knowledge, or suggesting new content you’d like to see. Every submission is carefully reviewed, and approved contributions are added to support and strengthen the entire billing community.
Is your team still writing every claim note by hand?
The Claim Note Tool builds each claim status note in seconds, in one standard format for your whole organization. Try it free for 1 week.
