How To Appeal

How to appeal a denied claim

Learn when an appeal is the right move, how reconsideration and appeal work, what to send with each denial, and get an editable appeal letter in minutes. Download it as Word or PDF.

2 levels of appealDocuments by denial typeFree editable letter

Should you appeal?

An appeal is for a claim the payer has fully processed and denied, when the problem cannot be fixed by correcting the claim and sending it again.

Correct and resubmit

Use this when the denial is a billing mistake you can fix: a wrong ID, a missing modifier or a typo in the patient details.

Appeal

Use this when the claim was billed correctly, or you have proof the payer’s decision is wrong, such as proof of timely filing, records or an authorization.

Adjust or write off

If you have no proof and no valid reason, follow your client’s adjustment rules. A weak appeal wastes time for both sides.

The two levels of appeal

Most payers use two steps. The first is called reconsideration. If the payer upholds its denial, you can send a second-level appeal.

  1. 1Denial received
  2. 2Confirm the rules with the payer
  3. 3Reconsideration (first level)
  4. 4If upheld: appeal (second level)
  5. 5Paid, adjusted or external review

Each level has its own deadline, and the first-level and second-level letters or forms can differ. Always confirm both with the payer.

How to appeal, step by step

1Read the denial

  • Find the denial code, the reason and the denial date on the EOB or remit.
  • Check whether the payer printed appeal instructions or a deadline.

2Decide: fix or appeal

  • If a correction solves it, resubmit the claim instead.
  • If the payer’s decision is wrong, continue with an appeal.

3Confirm the rules

  • Call the payer or check the portal for the appeal level, the deadline, the address or fax and whether they need their own form.
  • Ask which submission modes they accept. Choose portal or fax first, as they arrive faster than mail.
  • Write down the call reference number.

4Gather documents

  • Pick the proof that matches the denial. See the list by denial type below.
  • Send only what supports the reason for this patient and this claim.

5Write the letter

  • Use the payer’s own appeal form first. It is the best option. Find your insurance’s form.
  • If the payer has no form, use our editable appeal letter and replace the highlighted placeholders.
  • Get client approval for the wording if your client requires it.

6Submit on time

  • Send one package: the letter first, then the supporting documents.
  • Keep proof of sending: the fax confirmation, the portal confirmation number or the mail tracking number.

7Follow up

  • Note the account with the date, the mode, the reference number and the payer’s review time.
  • Check the status once that review time has passed.

8Handle the result

  • Overturned: confirm the payment and post it.
  • Upheld: check whether a second level is open and its deadline.
  • No appeal rights left: adjust the balance as your client directs.

Get your appeal package ready

Appeals often need PDFs fixed or combined before they go out. Do it free in your browser. Your files are never uploaded.

  • Fill in or edit a payer’s appeal form
  • Cover details that do not belong in the package
  • Merge the letter and records into one file
  • Compress it to fit a portal or fax size limit

What to send with each denial

Every appeal needs a letter or form and supporting documents. These are the documents that usually help for each denial type. Always follow what the payer asks for.

Timely filing

Send proof of timely filing (POTF) that shows the date the claim was submitted. Any of these can work:

  • Clearinghouse submission report
  • Payer acknowledgement or acceptance report
  • EDI acceptance screenshot

Open the matching letter →

Records requested or insufficient documentation

  • Visit notes and records for the date of service
  • Records must support the code that was billed

Open the matching letter →

Medical necessity

  • Clinical notes showing why the service was needed
  • Letter of medical necessity from the provider
  • The payer policy or guideline that supports the service

Open the matching letter →

Authorization or referral

  • Approval letter or authorization number
  • Referral on file for the date of service

Open the matching letter →

Coding or modifier

  • Notes that support the code and modifier billed
  • Coding guideline that backs the billing

Open the matching letter →

Eligibility or coverage

  • Proof the patient was covered on the date of service
  • Primary insurance EOB for coordination of benefits

Open the matching letter →

Timely filing without proof? If you cannot prove the claim was filed on time, adjust it as your client directs. If a delay had a real reason, such as a late eligibility response or a payer system problem, you can explain it in the appeal, but only if it is true and you can support it.

Need an appeal letter?

Start with the insurance company’s own appeal form. It is always the best choice, because the payer already accepts it. If your payer has no form, or accepts a letter, use our free editable template.

1. Find the payer’s own form

Download the official appeal form for popular insurances, or open the payer’s own appeals page, all in one place.

2. No form? Use our letter

Type your own details over the placeholders, change the wording and fonts, then download it as Word or PDF. We never ask for patient or provider information.

Medicare appeal levels

Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) has five levels. Deadlines run from the date you receive the notice, which is generally presumed to be 5 days after the date on it.

LevelWho decidesDeadline to fileMinimum amount
1. RedeterminationMedicare contractor (MAC)120 days from the initial determinationNone
2. ReconsiderationQualified Independent Contractor (QIC)180 days from the redetermination noticeNone
3. ALJ hearingOffice of Medicare Hearings and Appeals60 days from the reconsideration notice$200 in 2026
4. Council reviewMedicare Appeals Council60 days from the ALJ decisionNone
5. Federal courtU.S. District Court60 days from the Council decision$1,960 in 2026

Commercial plans, Medicaid and Medicare Advantage set their own levels and deadlines, often in the provider contract. Confirm them with the payer on every account.

Common appeal mistakes

Missing the deadline. A strong appeal sent late is usually rejected. Note the deadline when you open the account.

Skipping the payer’s form. Some payers refuse a general letter when they have their own form.

Sending the wrong proof. Match the documents to the denial reason, and include the pages that support the billed code.

No proof of sending. Keep the fax confirmation, portal number or tracking number in the account notes.

Appealing without a reason. If nothing supports the claim, adjust it as your client directs.

Mixing patients. Check every page belongs to this patient and claim before you send, to protect privacy.

Would you like to help our billing family?

Help us keep MBillers accurate and up to date by reporting incorrect information, sharing valuable medical billing knowledge, or suggesting new content you’d like to see. Every submission is carefully reviewed, and approved contributions are added to support and strengthen the entire billing community.

Is your team still writing every claim note by hand?

The Claim Note Tool builds each claim status note in seconds, in one standard format for your whole organization. Try it free for 1 week.